Skip to content
Last
settled
FreakBets

Premier League clubs vote 18-2 to cover board's legal costs if City sponsors sue

Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were reported as the two clubs against a rule change that protects five directors from the cost of possible defamation claims.

By FreakBets Newsroom

Premier League clubs have voted 18-2 to cover the legal costs of the competition's five board directors if Manchester City's sponsors sue them individually over the league's financial-breach ruling against the club.

The vote was held at a meeting of the clubs in central London on Thursday 19 November, Sky Sports reported. A two-thirds majority of 14 clubs was needed, and the proposal cleared that bar with room to spare.

Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the two clubs reported to have voted against, according to BBC Sport.

What the clubs have agreed to

The protection covers chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder.

Under the old rules, a director was financially protected only if they won a legal case brought against them, BBC Sport reported. The amendment extends that protection to potential legal costs arising from claims against the directors.

Sky Sports reported that the proposal concerns possible individual defamation claims against board members by Manchester City's sponsors.

The change comes with strings for every club in the division. BBC Sport reported that collective responsibility means all Premier League clubs are liable to cover the board's legal costs. That creates the possibility of City contributing financially to legal action brought by its own sponsors.

The Independent reported that the amended rules place no upper financial limit on the liabilities shared among member clubs. It also reported that the governing articles in question had not been examined since 1992.

Forest's objection was procedural, according to Sky Sports. The club believed insufficient information had been provided and that there had not been enough time to consider the implications.

Why the sponsors are involved

The vote follows an independent commission's finding in September that Manchester City breached more than 100 Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018.

Sky Sports reported that the commission described City's commercial contracts as part of a "disguised funding scheme" that artificially inflated the club's revenues by £830m. The Independent reported the same figure, saying the commission found revenues had been inflated through "sham" agreements between 2009-10 and 2017-18.

The commission also said City had failed to cooperate and act in good faith during the investigation, Sky Sports reported, with three of four alleged breaches upheld and one charge not proven.

Two of the club's sponsors have since indicated they may take the league to court. Etihad Airways, which has sponsored City since 2009 according to Sky Sports, said on 30 September that the Premier League had not engaged with it and that it had not been given the chance to provide relevant information. The airline said it was seeking legal advice to protect its interests.

Etisalat, the Abu Dhabi communications company, went further in its language.

"Emirates Telecommunications Group Company PJSC (Etisalat) views the published findings of the English Premier League, as they relate to Etisalat, as entirely false and defamatory," it said. "Etisalat is actively considering all options relating to its rights and associated legal remedies in this matter."

City's position and what comes next

City are appealing the ruling, and sanctions have not yet been determined, BBC Sport reported.

The club has rejected the commission's findings outright. "Manchester City is both disappointed and surprised by the opinion of the Premier League commission that has been published today," it said in response to the ruling.

"The club is innocent of the accusations made by the Premier League and a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists in support of all of its positions relating to this case."

The 18-2 margin shows where the rest of the league stands on protecting its board. With an appeal pending, sanctions undecided and two sponsors weighing legal action, the directors now know the clubs will stand behind their costs. The clubs, in turn, have accepted a bill with no stated ceiling.

On the pitch, City host Fulham in the Premier League on Saturday 21 November at 12:30 UTC, before Napoli visit in the Champions League on Tuesday 24 November at 20:00 UTC.

Forest travel to Bournemouth on Saturday 21 November at 15:00 UTC and then host Chelsea on Friday 27 November at 20:00 UTC.

  • Premier League
  • Manchester City
  • Nottingham Forest
  • Richard Masters
  • Etihad Airways
  • Etisalat

Coming up

Sources

  1. BBC Sport — Premier League clubs to cover legal costs if Man City sponsors sue
  2. Sky Sports — Premier League clubs vote to cover legal costs if Man City sponsors sue competition’s board members
  3. The Independent — Premier League chiefs given extra legal protection amid threats of action from Man City sponsors

Written by the FreakBets newsroom with AI, using only the sources above, and checked against them automatically before publication. See our editorial policy.